For a time, Brock Purdy was the NFL’s ultimate underdog story. The final pick in the 2022 NFL Draft—“Mr. Irrelevant”—stepped into the San Francisco 49ers’ starting quarterback role under less-than-ideal circumstances and sparked one of the most efficient stretches of play in franchise history. He was poised, accurate, unshaken under pressure, and most importantly, he was cheap.
Purdy’s rookie-scale contract allowed the 49ers to build a roster loaded with star talent elsewhere: Christian McCaffrey, Deebo Samuel, George Kittle, Nick Bosa, and Fred Warner, to name a few. San Francisco was one of the few teams in the league able to contend for a Super Bowl while paying their starting quarterback less than most veteran backups. That rare financial flexibility gave general manager John Lynch and head coach Kyle Shanahan room to maneuver—and for a while, it worked brilliantly.
But the NFL economy is relentless. And as Purdy’s meteoric rise continued, so did the countdown to the inevitable: a massive payday. Now, entering his fourth season, the 49ers are no longer riding the wave of an underpaid quarterback. They’re staring down a contract negotiation that will dramatically alter the team’s structure and challenge its ability to keep their all-star supporting cast intact.
Purdy, by every reasonable standard, has earned his seat at the table. He led the league in passer rating in 2023, took the 49ers to the NFC Championship Game in back-to-back seasons, and helped guide the team to a Super Bowl appearance—all while earning less than $1 million per year. In today’s NFL, that level of production usually commands contracts in the $45–55 million range annually. And while Purdy doesn’t carry the same name cachet as a Patrick Mahomes or Joe Burrow, his résumé is already forcing the 49ers’ hand.
For San Francisco, this is the price of success—and of finding unexpected gold at the bottom of the draft. While Purdy was a bargain, the team was able to afford top-tier talent on both sides of the ball, creating a perfectly balanced roster. Now, re-signing him to a market-rate deal will likely come at the expense of that balance. Tough decisions are coming. Star players may need to be traded or allowed to walk. Depth will thin. And Shanahan may need to rely even more heavily on his system to compensate for what the team loses around its quarterback.
The irony is sharp: the very thing that made the 49ers so dangerous—elite quarterback play at a discount—now threatens to unravel the foundation of their roster. The franchise must now transition from one phase of team-building to another, one that most successful franchises eventually face: building around a paid quarterback and sacrificing elsewhere.
Of course, it’s not all doom and gloom. Having a legitimate franchise quarterback is still the most valuable asset in the sport. The 49ers are likely to secure Purdy’s services for the long term, and that kind of stability is something few teams enjoy. But the days of a loaded roster supported by a rock-bottom quarterback salary are over. And that changes everything—from how the 49ers draft to who they re-sign to how they construct their future championship windows.
Brock Purdy was a historic bargain. Now, like all good things in the NFL, that window has closed. The 49ers have their quarterback. But they’ll soon discover what it really costs to keep him.
Leave a Reply