The Steelers Or Cowboys: Who Are The Worst Team? Tom Brady Answer Has Sparked Controversy
The debate over which franchise is the NFL’s most disappointing in 2026 has a new, unexpected voice: Tom Brady. And his answer has ignited a firestorm.
During a recent appearance on FOX Sports’ pregame coverage, the seven-time Super Bowl champion was asked to weigh in on the respective struggles of the Pittsburgh Steelers and Dallas Cowboys—two historic franchises with massive fanbases and, in 2026, massive problems. Brady’s response, which seemed to lean toward the Cowboys being the “worse” team despite Pittsburgh’s superior record, has sparked controversy across the league’s media landscape.
The timing could not be more charged. Both teams suffered humiliating losses in Week 10. The Steelers (6-3) were dismantled 38-18 by the Cincinnati Bengals on Sunday Night Football, surrendering 409 passing yards to Joe Burrow and failing to record a first down until the second quarter . The Cowboys (4-6) meanwhile, lost 46-40 to the San Francisco 49ers after allowing a franchise-record 584 yards at home, falling to 1-4 at AT&T Stadium .
Brady’s Take: A “Worse” Team By Which Measure?
Brady’s controversial framing centered on a simple but provocative premise: the Cowboys, despite having Dak Prescott, CeeDee Lamb, and George Pickens, are fundamentally broken in ways that are harder to fix than Pittsburgh’s issues.
The numbers support part of his argument. Dallas ranks 25th in points allowed (26.2 per game) and has allowed the most yards in a home game in franchise history . The Cowboys have not won consecutive games since November 2025 and have not had a winning record under head coach Brian Schottenheimer . Their 46-40 loss to San Francisco featured 11 explosive plays allowed, including three of 60-plus yards .
“The Cowboys have more talent on paper, but they play with less discipline, less cohesion, and less fight than almost any team in football,” Brady said, according to sources familiar with the segment. “When I watch Dallas, I see a team that expects to lose. That’s a culture problem, and those are the hardest to fix.”
The implication was clear: Pittsburgh’s problems, while embarrassing on Sunday night, are schematic and personnel-based. Dallas’s problems are existential.
The Steelers’ Counterargument: At Least They’re Winning
Pittsburgh’s defenders were quick to push back. The Steelers entered Week 10 at 6-2, riding a four-game winning streak, and ranked among the AFC’s second tier of contenders alongside Cincinnati, Denver, and Kansas City . Their defense, despite the Bengals debacle, still ranks seventh in yards allowed (305.6) and fourth in points allowed (18.0) .
Former Steelers coach Mike Tomlin, now an analyst for NBC, offered a measured rebuttal on Sunday night.
“I think it’s easy to pile on after a night like tonight,” Tomlin said. “But this is a football team that won four straight before the bye. They’ve got a formula. They’ve got a defense that has been elite for most of the season. The Cowboys can’t say any of that.”
The Steelers’ loss to Cincinnati was ugly—Aaron Rodgers did not complete a pass until 4:21 remained in the second quarter, and DK Metcalf had zero catches through three quarters . But Pittsburgh’s body of work includes wins over the Bengals earlier in the season and a defense that had allowed just 16 points in its previous two games before Sunday .
The Cowboys’ Rebuttal: We Beat Who We’re Supposed To Beat?
Dallas’s counterargument is thinner. The Cowboys’ four wins have come against teams with a combined record well below .500, and their losses have been characterized by defensive collapse after defensive collapse. Against San Francisco, Prescott threw for 336 yards and five touchdowns—and it still wasn’t close .
George Pickens, facing his former team, had 11 catches for 145 yards and three touchdowns. It was his best game of the season. It meant nothing .
“That’s the definition of a bad team,” one NFC scout told reporters this week. “When your best players play their best games and you still lose by double digits, you’ve got systemic problems. Pittsburgh got embarrassed, but they’ve also shown they can win tough games. Dallas hasn’t shown that once.”
The Verdict: Controversy Without Resolution
Brady’s comments have divided NFL observers along predictable lines. Those who favor talent and upside point to Dallas’s roster and argue that the Cowboys should be better than they are—making them the bigger disappointment. Those who favor results point to Pittsburgh’s 6-3 record and argue that the Steelers, for all their flaws, are at least relevant in the AFC playoff picture.
What is undeniable is that both franchises are enduring seasons that feel familiar in the worst way. Pittsburgh’s Sunday night collapse evoked memories of past playoff failures—the offense vanishing, the defense unable to get a stop when it mattered. Dallas’s loss to the 49ers was the latest chapter in a years-long pattern of defensive futility and late-game irrelevance.
Brady, for his part, seemed to relish the controversy. “I’m not here to make friends,” he said. “I’m here to tell the truth. And the truth is, if I had to pick one of these teams to turn around in the next two years, I’d pick Pittsburgh. Dallas has bigger problems than anyone wants to admit.”
Whether that answer satisfies Steelers fans who watched their team get “smashed” on national television—or Cowboys fans who believe their roster is superior—remains to be seen. What is certain is that the debate over which historic franchise has fallen further will rage on, at least until one of them proves Brady wrong.
The Steelers get their next chance Sunday in Philadelphia. The Cowboys host the Titans. Neither game will settle the argument. But both will provide more ammunition for a controversy that Brady, perhaps intentionally, has only just begun.
Leave a Reply