Cowboys Make Major Decision on Injured $33 Million Star
FRISCO, Texas — The Dallas Cowboys have decided against shutting down their most expensive free-agent acquisition of the offseason, even as his return timeline remains stubbornly uncertain.
Head coach Brian Schottenheimer confirmed Monday that safety Jalen Thompson, who has been sidelined since Week 3 with a hamstring injury, will not be placed on season-ending injured reserve. The team is not considering shutting him down for the remainder of the year, according to comments relayed by The Dallas Morning News .
The decision ends weeks of speculation about Thompson, who signed a three-year, $33 million contract in March—the Cowboys’ largest outside free-agent investment in more than a decade . He has played just 167 snaps this season and has yet to have his 21-day practice window opened, meaning his return remains clouded .
Thompson suffered what was described as a Grade 2 hamstring injury in Week 3 against the Ravens in Rio de Janeiro. The original projection called for a four-to-eight week absence, a window that has now passed . The fact that his practice window remains closed nearly two months later has been a source of quiet frustration at The Star, where the safety group has been decimated by injuries.
Stephen Jones offered a sliver of optimism late last week, telling 105.3 The Fan in Dallas that Thompson is “making progress” and would “certainly be in play” for Week 11 against the Titans . But Monday came and went without the expected roster move, leaving the Cowboys in a familiar holding pattern.
The stakes are difficult to overstate. Dallas’ defense has been a season-long catastrophe, allowing 584 yards in a 46-40 loss to the 49ers on Sunday . The secondary is now without cornerback DaRon Bland, who suffered a high-ankle sprain against San Francisco and will “miss some time” . Starting guard Tyler Booker also went down with an ankle injury that Schottenheimer classified as a “big one” . The Cowboys are 1-7-1 and staring at a closing stretch that includes a Thanksgiving matchup with the Eagles.
Thompson was supposed to be the antidote to those problems. Instead, he has been a ghost. Pro Football Focus ranked the signing among its favorites of the offseason, citing his consistency in Arizona, but the durability concerns that followed him to Dallas have proven prescient . He recorded seven interceptions across the 2021 and 2023 seasons but has not picked off a pass since, and his coverage metrics had already begun to slip before the hamstring gave out .
For now, the Cowboys are betting that patience pays off. Opening Thompson’s practice window would give him 21 days to ramp up before a decision is required on activation, but the team has shown no urgency to start that clock. The most likely scenario remains a Week 11 or Week 12 return, though the lack of practice reps makes an immediate impact unlikely.
The alternative—shutting him down and preserving whatever value remains on his contract—was apparently never seriously considered. That decision carries risk. If Thompson returns and reinjures the hamstring, the Cowboys will have paid $22 million in guaranteed money for a player who contributed almost nothing to a lost season. If he stays sidelined, the investment looks even worse.
Schottenheimer is expected to provide another update Wednesday, when the team begins preparing for Tennessee. Whether that update includes an open practice window or another round of “week to week” ambiguity will go a long way toward defining what the remainder of Thompson’s first season in Dallas looks like.
For a defense that has already lost Bland, Booker, and a rotating cast of safeties, the margin for error is gone. The Cowboys have decided not to quit on Jalen Thompson. The question now is whether Thompson can finally reward that faith.
Leave a Reply